Illustration par défaut

The universal nature of stellar granulation unveiled

9 December 2013

The CoRoT satellite has provided the first clear photometric signature of the granulation in stars other than the Sun. These observations have also revealed the existence of an universal scaling relation between the characteristic time-scale of stellar granulation and surface parameters of the stars.
Observations made with the Kepler satellite (NASA) on a larger number of stars recently confirmed the CoRoT observations. These observations have motivated theoretical work led by researchers at the Paris Observatory (Observatoire de Paris / CNRS / Université Paris Diderot / UPMC). This work has resulted in a theoretical model of stellar granulation which reproduces satisfactorily the observed scaling relation. It allows us to better understand the properties of stellar granulation and its relationship with the properties of solar-like oscillations. This study was recently published in two articles in Astronomy & Astrophysics.

Illustration 1: Photography of the solar granulation. The granules have a size of the order of one mega meter (BASS2000 solar data base, Observatoire Midi Pyrénées)
Illustration 2: 3D hydrodynamical modelling of stellar granulation. The simulated domain has a size of a few mega meters in each direction (credit: M. Steffen)

The term “solar granulation” refers to a grainy pattern (also called granulation, see Figure 1) observed on the Sun’s surface and identified for the first time at the beginning of the 19th century by William Herschel. The first photographs of this phenomenon were taken by Jules Janssen (astronomer at the Observatoire de Meudon). It was not until the 1930s that these structures were definitively attributed to convective motions on the surface of our star. Since the mid-20th century, many more accuate observations were performed, and increasingly sophisticated models of solar phenomena were developed, particularly from the late 90s onwards with the help of three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations (see Figure 2).

These structures, which have sizes comparable to France, are very small compared to the size of the Sun. If it is relatively easy to observe them directly on the Sun, it is unfortunately not possible to visualize them directly on other stars. However, granulation constantly change over time, which produces very small fluctuations in the light of a star. The measurement of these fluctuations requires high precision instruments and long observation runs (weeks to months).

Thanks to its high photometric precision and long term observations, the CoRoT space mission was able to identify the signature of granulation in many stars [see Figure 3]. These observations also showed that the characteristic time-scale of this phenomenon varies approximately inversely with the characteristic frequency of the solar-like oscillations detected in the same star. This frequency (denoted numax) varies in turn as a function of two simple characteristics of the star: its gravity and surface temperature. The granulation time-scale therefore varies from one star to another in a self-similar manner, which gives the stellar granulation its universal character.

Illustration 3: Fourier spectrum of the CoRoT target HD 49385. The red curve corresponds to the signature of the granulation. The blue vertical line locates the characteristic frequency (numax) of the solar-type oscillations detected in this star.

Since this discovery, the Kepler (NASA) space mission has measured the properties of granulation in an even larger number of stars from the main sequence to the red giant phase, through the phase of sub-giant. These observations have confirmed and extended the validity of the scaling relation found by CoRoT.
This relationship remained so far largely unexplained. This has motivated a theoretical work which has resulted in a model of stellar granulation . This model was then compared with observations made with Kepler . The theoretical calculations required 22 three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations representative for the observed stars. These calculations confirm the dependence of the granulation time-scale with the characteristic frequency of the oscillations (numax). They reveal that this time-scale also depends on a characteristic number called the Mach number, which measures the ratio between the granule speed and the sound speed in the atmosphere [see Figure 4]. This number provides information about the velocity of the granules on the stellar surface.

This work allowed us to understand the partially unexplained link between the properties of the stellar granulation and those of the stellar oscillations. It finally reveals that this type of observations can provide a measure of the Mach number, which can be used as a constraint on models of stellar convection.

Illustration 4: Characteristic time-scale of stellar granulation as a function of the product Ma numax where numax is the characteristic frequency of the solar-like oscillations and Ma the Mach number (this number measures the ratio between the flow speed in granules and the sound speed). Filled circles correspond to measurements made with Kepler red giants (black) and less evolved stars (blue). The red squares correspond to theoretical values obtained for each 3D hydrodynamical simulations.

Notes
The CoRoT space telescope was launched December 26, 2006. Emerged from a French initiative, it was build under the project management of CNES in partnership with several French laboratories (CNRS) and cooperating countries (Europe, Brazil).

Kepler is a space observatory launched by NASA to discover Earth-like planets orbiting other stars. To know more about the Kepler satellite: http://kepler.nasa.gov/Mission/QuickGuide/

The 3D hydrodynamic simulations were calculated with the CO5BOLD code during the period 2005-2009 by the CIFIST team at GEPI (Observatoire de Paris). Each simulation required computational time of the order of months on a machine.